'Black Holes'
-a paper submitted to the course 'Evolving Universe'
(AST 200F) at the University of Toronto's Faculty of Arts & Science
by Giritharan, Navaratnam (V.N.Giritharan). Professor: Louis Noreau-
"The most incomprehensible thing about the Universe
is that is Comprehensible"
-Albert Einstein-
The purpose of this paper is to understand the
concept and the nature of the mysterious black holes. Nothing could escape
from black holes even light waves. Generally history of science shows ,
that the idea of black holes goes back at least two hundred years to a
time when there were two theories about light: there are particles and
wave theories.
A Cambridge man , John Miichell pointed out in his
paper in 1783, in the 'Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society
of London' that a star that was sufficiently massive and compact would
have such a strong gravitational field, that light could not escape. Any
light emitted from the surface of the star would be dragged back by the
star's gravitational attraction, before it could get very far. Michell
suggested that there may be a large number of stars like this. A similar
suggestion was made a few years later by the French scientist the Marquis
De Laplace, in his book "The System of the World". But the modern concept
of black holes comes from Albert Einstein's theory of General Relativity.
His field equations predicts black holes and their properties.
Space-Time, Warped Space Time and Black Holes:
To understand the nature and properties of a black
hole, we should know the modern concept in physics about Space and Time.
Since the civilization Philosophers and Scientists have been trying to
explain Space and Time. Newton used common sense perspectives adopted by
ordinary people to explain space and time. According to Newton's view the
world changes from moment to moment. At any given moment the world is 'some
well defined state of the whole Universe'. In fact the world is seen
as the totality of all these objects at one particular time , Universal
moment. He thought as most people do, that the 'Space' and 'Time' are absolute;
concrete or Universal. But Einstein's 1905 paper on relativity 'The Special
Theory of Relativity' revolutionized the concepts of space and time. Space
and Time can be no longer considered as absolute instead they are flexible,
elastic (qualities) and relative. Their values depend on who is measuring
them from which frame of reference. According to this space
and time cannot be regarded as two separate entities anymore. Instead they
are one , called 'space-time'. It combines Space and Time into one physical
identity. Now Universe is regarded as as series of events in 'space-time'.
That is Universe is 'space-time' continuum.
Special Relativity revolutionized the concepts
of Space and Time, but 'The General Relativity' revolutionized the concept
of gravity. It describes matter as well as 'space-time'. Newton considered
gravity as a force, but according to Einstein gravity is no longer a force,
Instead a 'space-time' geometry. The mass of an object curves , warps the
'space-time' world around it. It bends or distorts the fabric of 'space-time'.
The geometry of this 'warped' space-time makes bodies like Earth to move
to follow the nearest thing to a straight path in a curved space which
is called Geodesic, shortest path between two nearby points. According
to 'General Relativity' the earth follows a straight path in four dimensional
'space-time' which appears to us to move along a circular orbit in three
dimensional Space. In fact, Black Holes are highly gravitational objects
which warp the 'space-time' world around them, so that nothing could escape
from their distortion of 'space-time'.
Formation of Black Holes:
So far we have been dealing
theoretically about black holes. Now, let us think about about a little
bit practically. In reality, how black holes are formed? To understand
this , we should know the process of Stellar Evolution.
Stellar Evolution:
A star is formed when
a large amount of gas , Interstellar Medium, starts to collapse , mostly
Hydrogen, on itself due to its gravitational attraction. As it contracts
the atoms of the gas collide with each other more and more frequently and
at a greater speeds. Finally, the gas will be so hot that when the Hydrogen
atoms collide they no longer bounce of each other but instead coalesce
to form helium. The heat released in this reaction makes the star shine.
THis heat also increases the pressure of the gas until it is sufficient
to balance the gravitational attraction and the gas stops contracting.
Stars will remain stable like this for a long time.
However eventually the star will run out of its hydrogen and other nuclear
fuels. When a star runs out of fuel, it starts to cool off and contracts.
During this contracting process, the burned out core be less than about
1.44 times ( the so called Chandrasekhar limit;Dr. S.C Chandrasekhar, a
well known scientist from Tamilnadu, India received nobel prize for his
research on 'Black Holes'. ) the mass of our sun, The resultant object
is to become a white dwarf. If this mass lies between 1.44 and 3 solar
masses, the result is a neutron star. This added mass makes star to crush
its matter beyond atomic identity driving the electrons into the protons
and making neutrons. If the remnant has amass greater than about
3 solar masses, gravity wins out. Even tightly packed neutrons cannot withstand
the gravitational pull. The objects starts to collapse forever. That is
the case of Black Holes.
The German physist Karl Schwarzschild found the relationship
of critical radius, called Schwarzschild's radius. According to him , any
object can be transformed into a black hole by the simple act of shrinking
it. The figure is a space-time diagram of the collapsing star. As time
passes the star grows smaller and eventually collapses within its Schwarzchild
radius. At this instant the horizon forms, inside the horizon the star
continues to collapse and shortly thereafter turns into a singularity.
Also represented in figure 2 are the paths of light rays. Ray A was emitted
from the surface of the star when it was fairly large. Ray B, emitted when
the star was smaller is more strongly curved. Ray C, emitted just before
the star has reached it Schwarzchild radius. Ray D, was emitted after hole
has formed. This ray is trapped and it falls into the singularity.
Figure 3 shows the curvature of space-time in the
hole's vicinity. Figure 4 shows the further collapse. The star grows smaller,
the curvature of space-time more distorted and severe. Finally the star
entirely vanishes and crushes into a singularity. What remains now is only
the curvature. Einstein's gravitational field equations predicts an another
object called 'White Holes'. Actually 'White Holes' are just time reversed
Black Holes. They emit light all the time; shine steadily. A source from
which newly created matter spews forth into the Universe. Figure
6 shows a black hole ,a white hole and a 'worm hole' which acts as a bridge
connecting the black and white holes. The black and white holes may be
in the same universe separated by a huge distance or may be in the two
different universes. Although Einstein's field equations predict the possibility
of 'worm hole' type structures, it is not possible to travel across from
black holes to white holes due to the followings reasons:
One must travel faster than light in order
to pass safely through a worm hole. Secondly, the geometry of 'space-time'
represents worm hole exists only for a short period. As time passes, the
geometry evolves. Like Black hole a worm hole suffers a similar consequences.
In order to pass through it, one must travel very fast otherwise he or
she will be caught in the pinch and engulfed in a singularity.
Some Other Characteristics of Black Holes:
Black Holes, as Eric
Chaisson says in his book 'Relatively Speaking' are not cosmic vacuum cleaners.
They don't go out of their way to absorb matter. But if some matter does
happen to fall in through the normal pull of gravity, there is no way to
escape.
Black Holes permit matter to flow in only one
direction inward by absorbing , swallowing matter, they constantly increases
their mass and size. Event horizon depends on the amount of mass
entombed inside.
The famous theoretical physicist Stephen W. Hawking's
studies on Black Holes show the nature of the event horizons and the immediate
environment of the black holes. According to Hawkings, the area of the
event horizon might stay the same or increase with time; but it could
never decrease since the paths of light rays which form the event horizon
always move parallel to or away from each other. Also he pointed out
that the area would increase whenever matter or radiation fell into the
black hole or if two black holes collide and merge together to form a single
black hole. In the latter case the area of the event horizon of the final
black hole would be greater than or equal to the sum of the areas of
the event horizons of the original black holes. Hawkings explained
the above mentioned effect of the event horizons with the laws of Thermodynamics.
Another important prediction (and property) of Black Holes by Hawkings
is its emission of particles. According to quantum mechanics' uncertainty
principle rotating black holes should create and emit particles.
But Haw king's calculations shows even non rotating black holes create
and emit particles at a steady rate.
We know nothing could escape from black holes. In
this situation how emission is possible from black holes? Hawkings showed
using quantum theory that the particles do not come from within the black
holes but from the space just outside the black hole's event horizon.
Another important property of black hole is its tidal
stress effect, which means whatever falls into a black hole is subject
to great tidal forces or stress. Suppose, a person falling feet first into
a black hole would find himself stretched enormously in height while being
squeezed laterally. He would not stay in one place for more than a fraction
of a second after passing the event horizon. This falling matter is the
reason for Black holes' radiation. In falling matter emit radiation on
its own due to the rapid heating of matter by tides and collisions, before
the submersion below the hole's event horizon. Also, quantum mechanics
predicts that black holes might not last forever. They slowly evaporate
and at last explode, scattering their contents into the vast interstellar
space. Their life time just like an ordinary stars depends on their mass
as well.
Is it Possible to Travel Near Black Hole?
Space Travel near black hole is not possible for
human since the human body cannot withstand physiological stress more than
ten times the present gravitational pull. We normally feel earth's surface.
But we can send a mechanical robot in a spaceship designed to withstand
stressful conditions normally intolerable to humans. In this way we may
be able to study the vicinity of a black hole. But once it is inside
the event horizon, it is gone forever. It is lost in the space. Eternally
trapped inside different universe where our laws of physics do not
work. This is the big question of man kind. What is inside a black hole?
What lies within the event horizon? No one knows....
Some Observational Evidence....
Are these black holes really exist? Or they are just
a mathematical expression. But observations confirmed the existence of
black holes. The discovery of Cygnus X-1, in 1973 in the binary system
may have the clue to solve the black hole puzzle. This discovery provided
a valuable information to the theoretical physics. Binary stars travel
in pairs and orbits a common centre of gravity. Of one of the stars collapsed
into a black hole, the black hole would exert a gravitational force on
its partner. What astronomers found in the constellation Cygnus is that
kind of similar effect. We cannot rush to a conclusion. The invisible mate
may a star that is too faint to be seen.
Cygnus X-1 is a strong source of X-rays. According
to Hawkings, the explanation is the matter has been blown off the surface
of the visible star due to its invisible partner's strong gravitational
pull. As it falls towards the invisible mate, it develops a spiral motion
and gets very hot , thus starts to emit X-rays. However in this situation,
the unseen mate may be a small white dwarf, or may be a neutron star
or may be a black hole. But it is possible to determine the lowest
mass of the unseen mate from the orbit of the visible star. In the case
of Cygnus X-1, this mass is about six times the mass of the sun. According
to Chandrasekhar limit, this fits only for a black hole. It is too great
for White Dwarf or Neutron Star. So it must be a black hole.
Now we have more evidence for other black holes
in our galaxy and in the neighboring galaxy , 'Megellanic Clouds'. We also
have some evidence of a larger black hole , with a mass of about 100,000
times of our sun at the centre of our galaxy.
Mini Black Holes:
According to Hawkings there is a possibility such
that there may be more mini black holes than visible stars in our galaxy.
The extra gravitational attraction of these black holes may explain why
our galaxy rotates at the rate it does.
Another suggestion by Hawkings and some other Scientists
is that the pressure in the early Universe might be able to form a significant
number of 'Primordial' black holes. Discovery of these 'Primordial' black
holes will provide more clues about the early stages of the Universe.
Bibliography:
Barry Prker, Einstein's Dream, Pllenum Press, NY 1986.
Bertrand Russell, ABC of Relativity, Unwin Paper backs,
London 1985.
Eric Chaission, Relatively Speaking, W.W.Norton &
Co., NY 1988.
George Greenstein, Frozen Star, New American Library,
1983
George Camow, One Two, Thre..Infinity, Dover Publications,
1974.
John Boslough, Stephen Hawking's Universe, Avon Books,
NY 1985.
John Gribbin, Cosmic Coincidence, Bantom Books
Jayant. V. Narlikar, The Lighter side of gravity, W.H.Freeman
& Co., Sanfrancisco
Paul Davis, Other Worlds, A Touchstone Books.
Stephen W. Hawkings, A Brief History of Time, Bantom
Books, 1988
|